1258 Main Street, East Earl, PA 17519-9614 $439,000

Coming Soon

Email This Listing Print property details Setup Alerts/Notes Save to favorites Share property details
Make Appointment
Beds/Baths: 6/2.2
Interior Sq. Ft: 3,714
Acreage: 0.74
Age:135 years
Style:
Traditional
MLS#: PALA2079038
Subdivision: East Earl Twp
Design/Type:
Detached

Description

Professional pictures to come Spacious and full of opportunity, this 3,500+ sq. ft. duplex offers incredible versatility and income potential in a highly desirable location — just minutes from New Holland and right up the road from Shady Maple. Backing directly to Blue Ball Elementary, you’ll enjoy views of open sports fields and tennis courts — adding a sense of community, safety, and space that tenants and owners alike will love. Situated on .74 acres of flat land, this property features tall ceilings, generous living spaces, and multiple structures that expand its investment appeal. The detached garage provides additional rental income or storage potential, while the detached summer kitchen offers an ideal space to convert into a short-term rental, studio, or in-law suite. Estimated market rent projections; Unit 1258; $1,595 - $1,695 Unit 1246; $1,695 - $1,795 Two car garage - $75 per bay. Whether you’re a young investor looking to house hack or a seasoned investor seeking a value-adding asset, this property delivers. With its prime location, growing market demand, and flexible setup, this is a value-increasing opportunity that’s ready to reward the right owner. Don’t miss this chance to own a unique, income-producing property with room to grow and plenty of upside in one of Lancaster County’s most sought-after areas.

Taxes: $5,426
Home Assoc: No
Condo Assoc: No
Garage: Y
Basement: Y
Pool: No Pool
School Dist: Eastern Lancaster County

Features

Utilities
Hot Water Heating, Radiator Heating, Oil, None, None, Hot Water - Electric, Well Water, Public Sewer

Garage/Parking
Detached Garage, Driveway, Off Street, Additional Storage Area, Covered Parking, Detached Garage Spaces #: 2;

Interior
Attic, Floor Plan - Traditional, Basement Sump Pump, Unfinished Basement, Accessibility - 2+ Access Exits

Exterior
Stone Foundation, Composite Roof, Shingle Roof, Stone Exterior

Select a school from the following list. Schools are grouped by school type.
The schools on this list are selected by their proximity of up to 5 miles to the property address. Proximity does not guarantee enrollment eligibility. Please contact the school directly for more information on enrollment requirements.
* If there are more than 5 schools of any type within a close proximity, click on the button to see additional schools of that type near the search address.

Public Elementary (2 schools)

School District Grades Place Distance
Blue Ball Elementary School Eastern Lancaster County School District K–6 East Earl 0.12 mi
New Holland Elementary Eastern Lancaster County School District K–6 New Holland 3.11 mi

Public Middle (1 schools)

School District Grades Place Distance
Garden Spot Middle School Eastern Lancaster County School District 7–8 New Holland 1.83 mi

Public High (1 schools)

School District Grades Place Distance
Garden Spot Senior High School Eastern Lancaster County School District 9–12 New Holland 1.77 mi

Private (22 schools)

School Grades Place Distance
East Earl Amish Parochial School Mennonite K–8 East Earl 0.84 mi
Weaverland School Roman Catholic 1–8 East Earl 1.58 mi
Terre Hill Mennonite High School Mennonite 9–12 Terre Hill 2.06 mi
Shalom Mennonite School Mennonite K–8 Terre Hill 2.14 mi
Bridgeville School Mennonite 1–8 East Earl 2.22 mi
Union Grove Mennonite School Mennonite 1–9 East Earl 2.33 mi
Center Grove School Amish 1–8 New Holland 2.88 mi
Center Parochial School Mennonite 1–8 East Earl 3.09 mi
Beartown School Nonsectarian 1–8 Narvon 3.24 mi
Martindale Parochial School Nonsectarian 1–8 Ephrata 3.31 mi
Lincoln Independent School Mennonite 1–8 Ephrata 3.76 mi
Welsh Mountain Amish Parochial School Amish K–8 New Holland 3.91 mi
Meadow Creek Parochial School Mennonite 1–8 New Holland 4.02 mi
New Holland Early Learning Center Mennonite Preschool–K New Holland 4.02 mi
Hinkletown Mennonite School Mennonite Preschool–12 Ephrata 4.03 mi
Muddy Creek Christian School Mennonite 1–10 Denver 4.13 mi
Linden Grove School Amish 1–8 New Holland 4.2 mi
Pequea Mennonite School Mennonite 7–9 New Holland 4.51 mi
Sunny View School Amish 1–8 Narvon 4.77 mi
Windy Valley School Amish 1–7 Gordonville 4.79 mi
Red Well School Amish 1–8 Kinzers 4.84 mi
Zeltenriech School Amish 1–8 Gordonville 4.89 mi

© 2025 LiveBy. All Rights Reserved.

This report is a detailed community overview for East Earl (17519), Pennsylvania.

Community Quick Facts

  • Average travel time to work for people in this community: 24
  • Average salary of people in this community: $38,727

Community Summary

  • Population Density (ppl / mile): 302
  • Household Size (ppl): 3.19
  • Households w/ Children: 99%

Housing Inventory

  • Owned: 1,623 (74.8%)
  • Rented: 494 (22.8%)
  • Vacant: 53 (2.4%)
  • Total: 2,170

Population Demographics

The population of the community broken down by age group. The numbers at the top of each bar indicate the number of people in the age bracket below.

Total: 6,762
Households: 2,117
Median Age: 34.40

Climate and Weather

The Temperature chart displays average high and low values for January and July, and is designed to provide an indication of both seasonal and daily temperature variability. The Weather Risk Index indicates the calculated risk of each type of weather event occurring in the future. This risk is based on historical localized storm events and weather patterns. The national average for each type of weather event equals a score of 100, so a score of 200 would represent twice the risk as the national average, and a score of 50 would represent half the risk of the national average.

Temperature

Education

Highest Level of Education Attained

  • Less than 9th Grade: 19.0%
  • Some High School: 8.9%
  • High School Graduate: 35.7%
  • Some College: 13.6%
  • Associate Degree: 8.0%
  • Bachelor's Degree: 11.6%
  • Graduate Degree: 3.2%

Income by dollar range

Median Income: $73,750

Fair Market Rents

The Fair Market Rents show average gross rent estimates based on figures provided by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD).

  • One Bedroom: $576
  • Two Bedroom: $849
  • Three Bedroom: $1,156
  • Four Bedroom: $1,036

© 2025 LiveBy. All Rights Reserved.

Contact Information

Schedule an Appointment to See this Home
Request more information
or call me now at 302-285-0977

Listing Courtesy of: Keller Williams Elite , (717) 553-2500, klrw1040@kw.com

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website appears in part through the BRIGHT Internet Data Exchange program, a voluntary cooperative exchange of property listing data between licensed real estate brokerage firms in which Patterson-Schwartz Real Estate participates, and is provided by BRIGHT through a licensing agreement. The information provided by this website is for the personal, non-commercial use of consumers and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed.
Copyright BRIGHT, All Rights Reserved
Listing data as of 11/07/2025.

1258 Main Street, East Earl, PA 17519-9614

Share on Facebook
Share on X
Pin It
Copy Link
Email It

Broker Compensation

An offer of broker compensation or seller concession is not a guarantee. All compensation offers and concessions are negotiable and subject to written agreement between the parties. Please consult with your real estate agent for more information.